[Archived] The +/- Game

[RoverJoexx]

Like I mentioned in the Everton thread. Would like to try this little old game, just to see who comes up on top as the players majority of us would like to see

us succeed at the end of the season. Might be a long campaign. Hope I'm able to manage my time well to mend it daily.

Let's lay out the rules now;

1) Everyone only able to vote once daily( not going to keep track so I hope you guys be discipline enough )

2) There will be 4 departments to vote. They are Keeper, Defence, Midfield and Forward. Defence/Midfield will further breakdown to varies position.

3) Each time you make 2 '+' votes and 2 '-' votes but not all on the same player and votes make must be from different department.

Eg : You can't make 2 votes on Santa, and if you make a + vote on Santa you can't make your another + vote on forward department.

4) Each player will have 10 life. Any player that reaches 20 life will win in his position likewise those reaches 0 life will be oust.

5) Some players like Emerton will have more than one position which Ince had try to played them this season, just state their position when making the votes.

Keeper Dept:

Robinson- 10

Brown---- 10

Bunn----- 10

Defence Dept:

Rightback :

Ooijer---- 10

Emerton- 10

Simpson- 10

Leftback :

Warnock- 10

Olsson--- 10

Treacy--- 10

Centerback :

Nelsen------- 10

Samba------- 10

Ooijer-------- 10

Khizanishvili- 10

Mokoena----- 9

Midfield Dept:

Right Midfield :

Emerton---- 10

Reid--------- 10

Villanueva-- 10

Derbyshire- 10

Left Midfield :

Pedersen- 10

Treacy---- 10

Olsson---- 10

Center Midfield :

Dunn----- 11

Grella---- 10

Emerton- 10

Andrews- 10

Tugay---- 10

Reid------ 10

Mokoena- 10

Vogel----- 10

Forward Dept:

Santa------- 11

Roberts----- 10

McCarthy--- 9

Derbyshire- 10

Villanueva-- 10

Fowler------ 10

Pick your fav player and get your votes in now.

Votes updated as in post # 1

Will get the ball rolling first

+Santa

+Dunn

-McCarthy

-Mokoena(centerback)

[ABBEY]

+ derbs and tugs

- fowler and reid

[CrazyIvan]

+ Carlos (striker)

+ Andrews

- Ooijer (right back)

- Mokoena (centre back)

[rovers_rob]

+Treacy (Left Mid)

+ Fowler (Striker)

- MGP(Left Mid)

- McCarthy (striker)

[grizfoot]

+ Ooijer (Centreback)

+ Emerton (Centre Midfield)

- Mokoena (Centreback)

- Reid (Centre Midfield)

[Wolverine]

Santa +

Villanueva +

Reid -

McCarthy -

[percy]

Robinson +

Derbyshire+

McCarthy-

MGP-

[snatchymcsnatch]

+Carlos (Midfield)

+ Derbyshire

-MGP

-McCarthy

[Dreyski]

+ Warnock

+ Derbyshire

- Benni

- Reid

[RoverJoexx]

Keeper Dept:

Robinson- 11

Brown---- 10

Bunn----- 10

Defence Dept:

Rightback :

Ooijer---- 9

Emerton- 10

Simpson- 10

Leftback :

Warnock- 11

Olsson--- 10

Treacy--- 10

Centerback :

Nelsen------- 10

Samba------- 10

Ooijer-------- 11

Khizanishvili- 10

Mokoena----- 7

Midfield Dept:

Right Midfield :

Emerton---- 10

Reid--------- 10

Villanueva-- 11

Derbyshire- 10

Left Midfield :

Pedersen- 7

Treacy---- 11

Olsson---- 10

Center Midfield :

Dunn----- 11

Grella---- 10

Emerton- 11

Andrews- 11

Tugay---- 11

Reid------ 7

Mokoena- 10

Vogel----- 10

Forward Dept:

Santa------- 11

Roberts----- 10

McCarthy--- 5

Derbyshire- 14

Villanueva-- 11

Fowler------ 10

Pick your fav player and get your votes in now.

Encounter some problem as we can't keep editing on the first post. So I'll quote the updated progress every now and then.

Wolverine I've not put in your votes yet. Please state the specific position for your reid and villanueva.

Guys try not to put your two + or - votes onto players from same department.

[ihateburnley]

+ Olsson (defender) and Derbyshire (forward)

- McCarthy (forward) and Mokoena (midfielder)

[LeChuck]

+ Emerton (centre midfield)

+ Villanueva (left midfield)*

- Roberts

- Nelsen

* I don't know if I can do that as he's not listed there...but I'm sure, being left footed, that Ince must be considering that as one of his positions. If it's strictly from the list then I'll have + Ooijer (centre back).

[frosty]

+Tugay (centre midfield)

+Santa Cruz (forward)

-McCarthy (forward)

- Reid (centre midfield)

[James No. 7]

+ Emerton (CM)

+ Santa Cruz

- Reid (CM)

- McCarthy

[Rover down South]

+ Ooijer (CB)

+ Villanueva (midfield)

- Roberts

- Mokoena (CB)

[tchocky]

+ Simpson

+ Andrews

- Roberts

- Mokoena (midfield)

[Hasta]

+ Ooijer (centreback)

+ Emerton (central midfield)

- Pederson

- McCarthy

[Uddersfelt Blue]

+Olssen

+ Tugay

-Reid

-Mcarthy

[neekoy]

- Pedersen (Left Mid)

- Reid (Centre Mid)

+ Tugay (Centre Mid)

+ Fowler (Striker)

[LeChuck]

1) Everyone only able to vote once daily( not going to keep track so I hope you guys be discipline enough )

Okay...I just noticed this.

This thread will die pretty quickly unless the first post is updated. Is there any way the mods can make it so that other people can edit it?

[RoverJoexx]

Keeper Dept:

Robinson- 11

Brown---- 10

Bunn----- 10

Defence Dept:

Rightback :

Ooijer---- 9

Emerton- 10

Simpson- 11

Leftback :

Warnock- 11

Olsson--- 12

Treacy--- 10

Centerback :

Nelsen------- 9

Samba------- 10

Ooijer-------- 14

Khizanishvili- 10

Mokoena----- 6

Midfield Dept:

Right Midfield :

Emerton---- 10

Reid--------- 10

Villanueva-- 12

Derbyshire- 10

Left Midfield :

Pedersen- 5

Treacy---- 11

Olsson---- 10

Center Midfield :

Dunn----- 11

Grella---- 10

Emerton- 14

Andrews- 12

Tugay---- 14

Reid------ 3

Mokoena- 8

Vogel----- 10

Forward Dept:

Santa------- 13

Roberts----- 7

Derbyshire- 15

Villanueva-- 11

Fowler------ 11

Out : McCarthy(Fw)

We got our first casualty of the game. McCarthy is out. No surprises there I guess, not one willing to give him a chance when he's not helping on his own.

LeChuck - I'm being practical atm, I don't want a player top of our list yet Ince didn't play him there. Your Ooijer vote is in.

I know your concern, this game just started yesterday. Hope more will be warming to it, it's just a little game for us to come in everyday to make a vote for players they love to see excel at that position for us this season . Might hot up when the list gets smaller.

Being a regular reader here, think i'm able to cope with the demands later on but not when I'm alsleep.

[T4E]

Can people not just copy and paste the last post in to a new one and show their votes in there? For example -

Keeper Dept:

Robinson- 11

Brown---- 10

Bunn----- 10

Defence Dept:

Rightback :

Ooijer---- 9

Emerton- 10

Simpson- 11

Leftback :

Warnock- 11

Olsson--- 12

Treacy--- 10

Centerback :

Nelsen------- 9

Samba------- 9 (-)

Ooijer-------- 14

Khizanishvili- 11 (+)

Mokoena----- 6

Midfield Dept:

Right Midfield :

Emerton---- 10

Reid--------- 10

Villanueva-- 13 (+)

Derbyshire- 10

Left Midfield :

Pedersen- 4 (-)

Treacy---- 11

Olsson---- 10

Center Midfield :

Dunn----- 11

Grella---- 10

Emerton- 14

Andrews- 12

Tugay---- 14

Reid------ 3

Mokoena- 8

Vogel----- 10

Forward Dept:

Santa------- 13

Roberts----- 7

Derbyshire- 15

Villanueva-- 11

Fowler------ 11

[Ricky]

what happens if two people post at the same time though T4E

all goes up the spout a bit then.

[T4E]

Hmmm, true. Well if Joe comes on once a day to tot up the votes and make sure the running totals are correct then that should solve that problem, not to mention making it easier for him.

[Majiball]

Derb's +1 striker

Fowler +1 striker

Samba -1 CB

Reid -1 CM