Thats a good question. The obvious one I can think of is Tim Sherwood from when we won the league. Im not sure if there was anyone between him and Flitcroft.
Previous to this wasn't Kevin Moran our captain - or at least he seems to be wearing an armband when we won the full members cup.
I think Sutton, Wilcox and Carsley were captains between Sherwood and Flitcroft.
I think Glenn Keeley captained the Full Members Cup winning side, and Nicky Reid followed him as captain.
Did Kevin Moran perhaps captain the side that won promotion from the Second Division to the Premier League?