He has went from a world class England international, to a fat Man City pudding according to what alot of people have been saying.
I do agree with Hughesy though that he has pure potential and id jump at the chance of signing him.
He was a good player 2 seasons ago but since then he has been non-effective. The lad needs a good kick up the arse and needs to take a good look at his performances and motivation!!!
McCarthy is a dick. Let him leave. His overall performances have been terrible and lazy recently and his attitude sucks. Certainly give Derbyshire a chance. The guy is immense and 100% committed!!!
On a positive note, he is a fantastic striker of the ball, holds it up well and good at taking on defences. On a negative note, he can be very lazy and uninterested.
Still a top man and great signing!
Derbyshire has done very well this season and he can get alot better. He has a good footballing head, some pace and he can find the net. Give the fella a chance and lets see if he can prove alot of people wrong. I have alot of confidence in him. Keep it going Matt!