Football History 
You can search every stat by rankings.  The one I used for that list was a points table for each appearance made in the old first division or premiership table at the end of each year i.e for every first place 12 points is awarded, second 9 points and so on 
Tournament 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9  
English League (1889-2004) 
 12  9  7  6  5  4  3  2  1 
The first column refers to how many points a team receives for winning a tournament, the second for second place, the third for losing in the semi-finals or finishing 3rd in a league, the 4th for losing in the quarter-finals, etc. 
This was based of top flight football, you can also filter by euro victories, cup wins, goals scored blah blah blah 
If you do it by all club competitions it comes out like this 
Liverpool 
Manchester United 
Arsenal 
Aston Villa 
Everton 
Tottenham Hotspur 
Newcastle United 
Leeds United  
Sunderland 
Wolverhampton Wanderers 
Chelsea 
Manchester City 
Nottingham Forest 
Sheffield Wednesday 
Blackburn Rovers 
Derby County  
West Bromwich Albion 
Bolton Wanderers 
Burnley 
Preston North End 
Sheffield United 
Huddersfield Town 
Ipswich Town 
West Ham United  
Portsmouth 
Blackpool 
Leicester City 
Southampton 
Middlesbrough 
Bury 
Charlton Athletic 
Birmingham City  
The Wanderers 
Stoke City 
Queen's Park Rangers 
Notts County 
Cardiff City 
Old Etonians 
Wimbledon 
Oxford University  
Royal Engineers 
Norwich City 
Oldham Athletic 
Coventry City 
Bradford City 
Bristol City 
Watford 
Brentford  
Barnsley 
Clapham Rovers 
Crystal Palace 
Luton Town 
Blackburn Olympic 
Old Carthusians 
Queen's Park Glasgow 
Accrington  
Fulham 
Grimsby Town 
Brighton & Hove Albion 
Millwall 
Swansea City 
Bradford Park Avenue 
Carlisle United 
Darwen