I would agree that he was one of our best players, and agree again that it doesn't say much.
But the again, the view that I take is that he has to have several outstanding games to make up for the dire performances he put in last season, though he is not the only player that applies to.
I just look from a defenders perspective, as I am one, and think 'who would I rather not play against, who is going to give me a harder time'. My answer would be Matt everytime.
Or dickov. Or Gally.
Plus there is the question of attitudes but I am not even going to go into that. Hey, hope yorkie scores a hatful and we have a great season, not saying I am right, just trying to justify my beliefs!!
If he performs well, because he does have the talent, then of course he should be in the team. I am just surprised he got the chance in the first place.