It’s just common sense lads. The window closes on August 8th. To judge it before then is just odd. If we don’t get the defenders in then we’ve failed. End of.

Yes

Not only did he not deny it. It would appear that he’s confirmed Bormuth as one of the targets!

This guy!! ??? Nice one Marty! ?

Nothing has changed about my opinions. I posted something this morning which pretty much spelt out how I see us challenging for the top six. If we had a first XI which pushed Bennett, Mulgrew, Evans etc onto the bench then bearing in mind they featured heavily last season, it would mean we were progressing as a team. The young lads sit in behind the 18 and are in the squad / team if there’s any loss of form or injury. Like I said, it’s not difficult. I don’t know why you struggle so much tbh. Apart from that, I plated Johnson up for you all 24hrs before anyone else, told you that Buckley was going to be the star before they came back for preseason and have 100% maintained that I will not judge the manager on transfers until the transfer window is shut. What do you bring to the table pal? A load of whinging dressed up as ‘balanced’ debate as far as I can see.

Ffs...what spin? My opinion is that Evans is good enough to back up Travis and Johnson. Just like Darren Fletcher backed up a Scholes and Keane and Billy McKinley backed up Tugay and Flitcroft. Essentially, the back up is a lesser player, hence why they ‘back up’. But in terms of the squad, when Evans arrived he was backed up by the likes of Lowe, Akpan and Guthrie. So the fact that we’re now even discussing Evans as back up or for sale proves that we have progressed. imo Smallwood is not good enough but to simply say that they’re essentially both the same is to ignore Evans career in the championship and international caps vs Richie’s jobbing around League 1 career. Why is that so difficult for you to understand?

You’re overthinking this. It doesn’t matter what we’re paying him unless you’re paying the wages. The fact of the matter is that since he signed that contract we have now replaced him with Travis and Johnson. So from a fans point of view, why would we get rid of an international player who can back out team up? More importantly, teams who play for those top 6 positions need to have players of Evans calibre in their bench.

Ahhh so he was fit but DIDNT play? Ergo...??

I take your point on Bennett but with Ada and Nyambe chasing that position down he won’t hang on forever. Why will Mulgrew be a permenant fixture? He was dropped for Williams for the last two months of last season....so logic would say he’s only starting because Williams is injured. Rothwell has been our best player since March and I fully expect him to start.

I do. I think he’s a decent player and more than adequate back up to Johnson and Travis.

I don’t know mate. My feeling / hope is that at some point this season (by October) we will have settled down with the new players, including the expected two new defenders and we’ll have a bench of Leutwiler, Bennett, Mulgrew, Evans, Downing, Brereton and Graham with the likes of Buckley, Butterworth, JRC and Grayson / Magloire backing them up and a team of Walton Nyambe | Lenihan | German/Croat | Bell Travis | Johnson Armstrong | Dack | Rothwell Gallagher

But you you don’t know what they earn, who has or hasn’t enquired for them or if the club even wants rid of them? I would personally like to see Smallwood go but I’d want to keep Bennett and Evans as back up to the first team.

I wouldn’t bet on it!

Fair.

Ah, so 10 mins. Still think he prob had this one and waited until it sneaked out before going ahead. He usually says he needs to check it out first. Still can’t see many of you being happy if we do sign Ada and this guy. I’d put decent money on some grumbling if we signed Messi! “He’ll never do it on a cold Tuesday in Wigan!!” ???

Nope, tbf Sharpe tweeted around 2pm. Lyle Thomas (Of Sky) at 3pm and Sky got onto it around 4pm.

True, but he won’t have a job for long if he burns his bridges with the club. It looks like he broke the German defender story anyway.

Classic nothing. You’re making claims like you actually know what’s happening...you don’t.

Ahh I’m glad you cleared that up.

I can’t work out where this link has come from? Has Sharpe broken it?

The squad is only currently bloated in Midfield and the forward lines which effects Buckley and Butterworth. I can see the latter going out but I’m pretty sure that Buckley will be in the match day squad (bench) straight away. Grayson, Magloire and JRC are right in the mix as it stands with us losing Rodwell and Downing as well as injuries to Williams and Hart. My personal opinion is that Buckley is ready to impact the first team now. The wildcard is Grayson. All would benefit from a year in league 1 but we have to look at our own interests first.

My point was that if we had players in the first XI good enough to have those on the bench then we would be ready to go up...

We need squad players of that quality if we want to go up. If those four start regularly this season were not going up.

I did say ‘potential’ that...I also agree that Bennett and Mulgrew will start which isn’t good.

How could we possibly know? There was a lot of talk early on in the window about Hanley, Dann as well as stated interest in the Barnsley lad and of course Bauer. Latterly we’ve heard about interest in Skrtel and of course Adarabioyo as well as Mowbrays previous admission of interest in Cooper. I also know (from a coach at Rotherham) that we were interested in Ajayi. So there’s a potential that we’ve enquired on a dozen defenders? As well as probably the same amount of keepers. It’s just a case of which one drops first.