If they are both similar, surely you play the one who is most likely to develop, rather than one who is limited in that position. I like Nyambe, he's pacey, competes well and is more skillful than people give him credit for. Has a mistake in him and needs to work on his crossing but then so does Bennett.

'Tony and I' Bloody hope they are feeling pressure. As it should be.

To be fair Mani, Smallwood was given a new contract for no discernible reason. He was already struggling in this league when it was dished out. Otherwise he would have been out of contract this summer. So, I'd say that the blame lies with the manager to some extent. I don't blame Smallwood for not walking away. On the plus side though, he's probably the best keeper we own!

Call me cynical...but is that part of the Nuttall deal?

To be fair if we sign a couple of defenders it will be happy days !

Cant be right- there's no Bennett or Evan's on that list!

Plus points: he's free - so meets the defence budget. He probably hasn't done a full pre- season so TM won't need to select him till November. Negatives: Not played for Boro or Coventry. Looks the type that might wear ripped Jeans and a baseball cap. Decisions, decisions...who'd be a manager?

I'll bow to your knowledge on that. I know nowt about the lad. Wiki puts him as bang on 6ft. Not sure that makes him the aerialy dominant cb we need.

So released from QPR but good enough for us?

Would fit the bill as being free and cheap contract.

Yeay. Another one I've never heard of!

Don't follow footy (Rovers apart) as closely as I used to but never heard of him.

This is where things blur. There was talk of the lad from Croatia - Skoric. No nonsense defender, captain and 29 so bags of experience. Can't imagine he's on a fortune in that league and would probably jump at the chance of move. Fee would realistically be the lower side of £2mil. May not be a world beater but could he strengthen a championship side- undoubtedly. Exactly the type of player we should be looking at. Certainly more chance of making an instant impact and us more competitive than a young lad from the Prem at £10 mil who may or not be the next great thing. However, we've seen an absolute reluctance to buy a player at that age - no doubt due to lack of a future transfer profit. Semi Ajayi is another who would have been a great and affordable (given what we spent on Gallagher) signing. Offering instant improvement on what we had. Our transfer strategy worked best when cherry picking the best players from clubs lower than us. There's a lot throughout Europe! It's how we got our 2 best signings in Dack and Rothwell. We don't have the financial muscle to compete with teams around or above us. If we do sign anybody from those clubs, we either overpay (Brereton) or end up with players deemed no longer good enough at this level (Downing). I expect we will sign a player, possibly two but again these probably won't be the type that we fans expect or fill positions that are needed. They will be players with potential, who can play several positions - made with future value in mind. Rather than players who will slot in straight away and help win matches.

I said before, with Jones, Hanley and Duffy, we've made more by selling defenders than strikers. The most profitable area if the team.

Spot on post.

TM has been very quiet since Saturday by his standards. Let's hope he's busy landing defenders

Because -as Mowbray admitted- he can no longer zoom past a player. If you can't do that, you can't really be an attacking winger.

Yes. The repeating pattern is the experts continually making the wrong decisions? Football analysis is always fascinating. We don't see training sessions, work on tactics, have personal or professional freindships with these players. A manager lives inside that bubble and will react accordingly. As fans, we watch from a distance - have no bond to players and analyse what we see over 90 mins every weekend. You could argue we have a clearer view of the performance than those involved. Ex pros (Gallagher, Atko) have been scathing of the defence and some performances over the last 12 months. Do they know nothing or just compare what they see against other teams - using their judgement...just like the fans do.

I said in that thread he will do or die by this summer window. 4 days left to turn a league one defence into a championship top ten one...

I think there's a strong argument for a whole new back 4 - although I think Nyambe should be brought back at rb. Even Lennihan is replaceable. Which leads me onto to Dack - poor preseason and pretty anonymous yesterday. Time to sell?

I would have said 'barely adequate' before. Splitting hairs I suppose ?

Suddenly looking like a poor window now. Five days to sort the defence. At least 2 defenders and a decent keeper required.

So just shite all round then?

So basically the same as last season. That is an undeniably poor result against a team we should be beating. Defensive mistakes, conceding from corners. Learnt nowt.