January Transfer Needs

[chaddyrovers]

7 hours ago, roversfan99 said:

The Batth of this season is irrelevant. Its the one we had last season which determines whether any replacement is an upgrade or a downgrade.

Equally, Sanderson barely played for us last season and when he did he was not very good. For Derby he has done well and is ahead of Batth. But it doesnt mean he left a big hole here.

Maybe we should have signed Sanderson last season when we had the option. Would you have done that given what we know now

[Emerald Isle Rover]

7 hours ago, roversfan99 said:

The Batth of this season is irrelevant. Its the one we had last season which determines whether any replacement is an upgrade or a downgrade.

Equally, Sanderson barely played for us last season and when he did he was not very good. For Derby he has done well and is ahead of Batth. But it doesnt mean he left a big hole here.

And I think McLaughlin is of equal measure 

[47er]

14 hours ago, Emerald Isle Rover said:

Out of curiosity who is generous and why? All a game of opinions and context for me but would be interested to see what others think

my grading wouldn’t necessarily be based on their ability alone more coming into a shitshow and how I think they have performed 

Eh? How they have performed depends on their ability doesn't it?

[chaddyrovers]

6 minutes ago, 47er said:

Eh? How they have performed depends on their ability doesn't it?

Gudjohnsen, Alebiosu, Miller, McLoughlin has good signings. 

Baradji look like he will be. 

Some havent