It's all moot. Since he's from MLS, and we know all MLS players are crap, he must be crap.
As for the serious part, he had one of the greatest 12-month stretches you'll ever see from a keeper. I think all of our expectations became a bit high. Is he a bad keeper, no. Is he one of the top 2 or 3 in the Prem right now, no. Are we in good shape in that position now with him as the starter and Encks as his backup/understudy, I think so.