Emerald Isle Rover

Can’t agree on that one Burrows styles firpo tymon bryon Callum Doyle all had better seasons Was it because they played full seasons likely but a player can only be judged on games and availability

No im not Iv stated beck is quality I’m taking issue saying he’s been the best left back we have had in decades. keep up

Sorry but rovers99 is spot on here I do believe if your good enough age is irrelevant but when it comes to championship over 48 game season (2 cup games minimum) there has to be balance in playing him if cantwell was to get injured for a significant period of time we need other options other than tyjon to hold down the fort in that position look at rigg in his first year at Sunderland 20 odd appearances not reliant on him or pressuring him just giving him that experience and enough for him to say next season I’m going to compete regularly for first team spot

I forgot about that signing yea i think he’s a class little player but some of the comments on here tonight would make you think we have lost maldini to derby

Let me clarify my point on beck I think beck is a class wee player and can go on to do well but in order to call a player the best in that position for a certain club over the last 15/20 years surely you would have had to play more than 25 games to even be considered in that conversation That’s my point

Your right they did forgot about him pushes beck closer to the exit door

No but I’d suggest that you would need to watch a player for more than 25 games for them to be called your clubs best left back in decades or the last 15 years iv stated beck is good im not having hes been our best left back in the last 15 years and id say if you asked many managers ex players etc id be very surprised if he was even mentioned

Yes I’m sure you were hahaha

I’d rather have my opinion over a player who has played over 100 games for rovers with a player of the season to his collection also than somebody with potential but a poor injury record for us wasn’t it you last week said you heard noises from brockhall that de neve was terrible in training couldn’t do drills and had an awful touch - yea after you posted that there’s absolutely nothing from your account that can be taken seriously

Always gets me too lol brilliant

They have two left backs Robertson and tsimikas 31 / 29 hardly stacked - listen I think beck can go on to be a very good player but to be made out on this forum he’s something he isn’t is baffling to me he missed 20 games through injury last season started 22 and sub 2

There’s a difference between generational talents and good players are you saying beck is going to be one of the best left backs in England and sought after by many of Europe’s finest?

So to be clear here Conor Bradley broke into Liverpool senior team at the age of 20 had one loan before hand beck is 23 next month this will be his 4th loan Not sure that’s the same path

‘Future’ what’s he achieved as of now mid table Scottish league a half good season at rovers and now a move to a team who just stayed in the championship he’s not maldini and Ribeiro is an equal at worst

Nothing to do with me being Irish I think beck can and will go on to be a very good player but the best left back we have had in decades or the last 15 years as you put it is mental 24 games if we are judging players on 24 games then I give up

So explain this then please

Derrick Williams was better and then converted to left sided centre back. Not sure how a player who played less than 25 games can be called the clubs greatest left back in decades very bizarre take Being fit is just as important as other attributes beck has the potential to go on and be very very good but your statement is a massive overreach

Not sure if this is serious or not and if it is ok have what your smoking

Yea real purpose they are showing signing two mid 30 year olds and loaning a left back 3 players not likely to be there next season paid significant money for a striker who is very unproven and not that I buy into ‘fan’ takes there’s a lot of Americans laughing at the signing if this was us last year you would be on here skating all of the above show more balance

Hardly a kick in the nuts to us - good signing though if he can stay fit

I do agree I think he’s been badly advised or his own perception might be slightly miscued. However Dolan is a decent championship player and to compare him to hedges is laughable really I’m fine with people having their own opinions but when debating or making comparisons at least do it with something tangible to back it up

Well to be fair there is evidence to suggest the later given the Turkish club presidents comments about him wanting ‘premier league move’ so it is fair for fans to say on the back of that he is maybe searching above his station as there’s nothing in his performances or stats to suggest he would warrant a premier league move

Hence we put some sort of clause in that if he gets a certain amount of minutes he plays here. If not then yes move him on

The tyjon dilemma I think most posters are right in their views I do think ideally another 10 would be better so he isn’t flogged but I also do think the only way of knowing if he’s as good as we/other clubs think he is we should be using him. As mentioned before Sunderland used 3 teenagers last year with great effect Now it’s not proven that works all the time but to incentivise him staying make him sign a pro deal give him minutes and let’s see if the hype is real

That is the same for all talent in all championship clubs though not just rovers