Mowbray back on Saturday so hopefully we hear something by Monday

Believe me getting his fitness back didn't work.If you read my post properly I said if he got fit and in shape become actually be decent but it's not going to happen in my opinion. I watched him in league one last year ,did you?He wasn't good enough

How much have you seen of him last couple of years?Can t be much because he has hardly played!

So nothing to do with the fact he has let himself go and looks like a pub player now? I highly doubt he is on better money here than he was at Birmingham and apart from that he only had a short spell at Bury who again where no way paying him as much as he was on at Birmingham You don't have to defend everything Scottish you know

Oh I agree Caddis should be moved on but if not we still need better cover than him.I highly doubt he will get his fitness sorted it's due to that he was let go from Birmingham as he was captain before he let himself go

So you think Caddis is championship standard?Sorry Chaddy but no way is he good enough in my opinion.If he looked after himself and got in good condition then i think he would be but I don't see it happening.Released by Birmingham and failed to win a contract at Bury that's enough evidence to suggest he isn't the standard required. Has Mowbray ever played Travis at right full back?I don't think he has so it looks like Mowbray see's him as a midfielder. I can definitely see the argument for bringing in another right back but I would be starting Nyambe.Seems Mowbray feels the same if the rumours of us looking at that Mellor from Blackpool are true

Hernandez Hernandez will want huge wages, no chance him coming here in my opinion. You sure Olivera is out of contract?I'm sure I read Norwich are willing to sell him and want 8 million?

I agree we do need stability and I'm not saying I agree with managers getting sacked every 5 minutes but it's the way the game Is now. I want to see how we do next season before I start advocating a new contract for Mowbray.Like I said there is no rush he has a year left and there is a year option. I'm not saying I don't think he has done a good job he has but he did what was expected of him last season, we where promotion favourites ,had the biggest budget and he even said himself that if he didn't get us promoted he wouldn't be much of a manager. Let's see where the club is in 12 months time before we start talking about a new contract for the manager imo

He is contracted for another year with a 12 month option after that. We don't need to be giving him another new deal. Mowbray has done very well but a manager is always in danger of being a few bad weeks away from the sack. I'm tired of the club forking out stupid amounts to pay people off. I'd rather we where looking to give the like's of Dack improved contract

Sky reporting Livermore will be on stand by

I would take Lallana,Yeah been injured but he wouldn't be in the squad if he wasn't fit he is quality and can make something happen coming off the bench if he had been fit all season he would be a starter in my opinion.The other 3 i agree with you

It wasn't a dig, he had 1 good season for Swindon moved on to QPR and did absolutely nothing.They let him leave for free or a nominal fee which shows they didn't think he was the standard required.Since he joined us he has done nothing except steal a wage,granted he has been injured but he isn't a good player

Caddis looks like someone who plays Sunday league football Chaddy.Not good enough for league 1 certainly not good enough for championship. Released by Birmingham and failed to win a contract at Bury.Not good enough. Yeah you did explain about Gladwin , that he had a good season at Swindon.Sorry didn't realise you used to watch Swindon on a regular basis.

Why do you want to sell Wharton?Can't say iv seen enough of him to make a judgement on him either way but thought he was highly rated by the club and was given a new contract? Why so keen to keep Gladwin he has a decent season a few years ago that earned him a move to Qpr since then he has done absolutely nothing. And Caddis why on earth do you want us to continue paying him a wage he isn't fit enough

I have asked the same of him before.Never got a reply to it though He wants to sign 6 or 7 players, give the youth a chance, keep the like's of Gladwin, give another contract to Conway etc I'm sure he wants us to have a 40 man squad

The transfer window opens the end of this week?Or so I read on sky sports website Yeah just seen it's opening on Thursday

When is Mowbray due to go to India?

Disagree with you on us having no good right backs Nyambe has improved a lot this year and I expect him to get better.He is only 20.Would like another right back to come in but after we hopefully find Caddis a new home

McBurnie a rangers fan I read so that alongside playing in front of a big crowd would be a major pull I'd say

I'd be bringing in Armstrong on loan or permanently, if we do play two up top then he would be the pacy option. I like the look of that McBurnie from Swansea but papers speculating that Gerrard is going to make him his first signing for Rangers. I don't know bigdogg like JH said it will depend on the budget but I'l be honest I don't want Rhodes coming back here,I don't rate him.

It's more likely we won't have millions though to be fair and id rather us be sensible with the money rather than forking out 20k a week to someone who hasn't done it in a couple of years. If we play the same system as we did last year then Rhodes would not be starting.Even if we do go two up top id prefer a target man and a pacy foward.

We have a limited budget so you think paying 20k a week for someone who would be on the bench is a cracking deal?We play one up front.Rhodes can't play that role, Dack is at his best feeding off someone who can hold up the ball like Graham.No point us even debating over this as I'l put my house on it that Rhodes won't be coming back here

An impact sub on 40 grand a week?Even if Sheff weds let him go for half his salary that's still 20k a week for someone who wouldn't be a starter

If we are playing one up front then would be a waste bringing in Rhodes on the wages he would be on and he will want to playing every week.Id be against Rhodes coming back

Which post?If it's the Jordan Rhodes on it was Glen Mullan who broke that story on here. As for the Seneca story, if I remember correctly you said the Venkys where selling the club? What about Rhodes to Bolton?Then Wigan? Raya to a premier league club for a pittance a couple of seasons ago? It does feel like you come on here at times and post things which would be bad news for us just to get a reaction and then play the lime "in my line of work I hear things " bla bla bla. Nothing against you personally but find it funny you very rarely ever here any positive rumours concerning Rovers from your "contacts"