Dreams of 1995

I don’t see a team being promoted with Pickering as left back. I’d say he is on the poorer side of full backs in this league. We are the only club he has played Championship football for. For context, Adam Henley had over 50 apps for us, and it transpired he was terrible I have lost count of the amount of goals we have conceded as a result of Pickering being beat or allowing the defender to run at him unchallenged. Same goes for Brittain actually, who I have lost patience with even for all of his attacking options If Pickering is the average standard for full back in this league then the standard is regressing

Blimey. We've gone back to Danny Batth He's not a very good defender. Never was, really. I can't believe people were begging to sign him last year when we had JDT With that said, he may actually be better suited to Eustace. He'd have got massacred with JDT as manager. Whereas with JE we are going to defend the box more, be deeper and invite teams on to us so we can try and break in the space behind Ayala was a good example of this kind of defender. Yes, he'd drop you a yard or three back, but in defending the box he was as good as any. Now Batth doesn't hold a candle to Ayala, but at this point it may make sense It shows how desperate we are though

If they cannot send funds from India then the club basically becomes insolvent They will have no choice but to sell, else they will fall foul of laws in the UK also It has been an unmitigated disaster for Venkys and Rovers. A partnership forged in hell. Madam must be regretting the day she ever said yes to this. It seems like she's the only one who has any brain power. The other pair just look like lost souls with too much money to throw around

When we were signing McGuire last season, I made a joke post about how it would all fall through It actually did fall through in a not so dissimilar way Experience tells me not to get excited about anything that happens with Rovers until it's printed in black & white. I like the fact we may be signing a goal scorer...I don't like the fact we have Waggott and Venkys doing the negotiation It is not outside of the realms of possibilities they fly the bloke over only to change the offer when he gets here.

This lad is 28 isn't he? It doesn't fit the "Venky model" of young and unproven. I suppose it does fit the cheap model. Either way, I'm still expecting the worse Fully expecting Microsoft to get the blame for it falling through

Men like Steve Waggott are symptoms of careless ownership He would not be allowed to get away with what he has if the owners had more than a fleeting glance at their Blackburn based enterprise once every 12 months When you look back at his time here, it has been failure after failure, with the most successful period being when he lost some semblance of control... The training ground development will go down as a failure on his part. Completely under estimated the mood of the fan base and the local residents of Brockhall The car crash interview around JDT and the coach - that's a low point, even under this lot The transfer 'errors', the stadiums' disrepair, the declining STs... all under his watch What is worse, is the man is paid handsomely for his time here. So he won't give a crap. He will continue to share a brew and biccy with the odd fan here and there whilst picking up 6 figures to basically be the fall guy of a declining business. Soon he will retire and never think of Blackburn or Rovers again. Someone else will have to pick up the pieces. It's criminal, really

That’s a bit of a mad link Will believe it when I see it though. It’s a long flight from Japan….anything can happen

Or maybe the man is going back to a Club he knows as unfortunately his body has been ravaged by injuries for him to play at a higher level? Dack is a horror story in football. Had the chance of PL football at one point. Injuries really set him back. I hope he finds some joy back at Gillingham

If they are in for Sammie, then he will go

You could say this about all posters

Turned out well for them And under Santos, it went excellently

I hope not Cooper played and was good in the Premier League. Batth was never trusted to play PL and instead loaned out or released as he fell down the pecking order Batth has been linked with the likes of Solihull Moors this year Not signing Batth was a good idea at the time. The fact we then signed McFadzean was a blow. He’s even worse than Batth Cooper is a better play than both. He will be our 2nd best defender….behind Carter

We came first in every group under Southgate. That isn’t luck. It is knowing what job you have to do and getting it done

Of course Carsley would come into consideration. He recently won the U21 European Championship Graham Potter may have prior to the Chelsea job. He had two excellent appointments in Sweden and then Brighton We seem to be the only major footballing nation who wants to take nationality out of the equation. All of the rest choose from the pool they have. I am not having this idea we can’t win it with an English manager. We need to improve our coach development for sure, but in Howe, Potter or Carsley, we have 3 good options to pick from. It would be Howe for me

It doesn’t come down to luck. I like how you shoe horned it in, but there’s nothing lucky about qualifying and then performing well at major tournaments But it is different from club football. You don’t get as long with players to mould the tactical shape you may want. It’s man management, maintaining harmony and playing the team in front of you rather than sticking to a specific philosophy And so history has shown, managing at club level and achieving success at club level is neither here nor there to making a success at international football Graham Potter had a very successful time at Brighton and before that in Sweden. Chelsea are a basket case - I will let him off. We could do a lot worse than Potter It is perhaps too early for Carsley. But having already won a tournament, you would say his destiny could be in the national job. I wouldn’t be against him, especially as a few of the players have already played under him and won I wouldn’t say that the best club managers are suited for international football. I would obviously back Pep if he was chosen, but there’s the argument that his methods require meticulous coaching. He will not get that time with a national team. You’d be a brave man to say he wouldn’t be successful, but that doubt would always be there. There’s countless examples of that - Flick, Trappatoni, Capello and most famous of all Don Revie. All very successful at club level and struggled for their national team

Au contraire Gav, I think entirely the opposite Transfer threads and rumours are driven by rumour. I first started reading this forum around a transfer window and was impressed at the amount of people who had 'inside knowledge'. Some didn't happen, some did, but you are infinitely more informed by reading this board than waiting for the LT But the mood in recent times has shifted. There's quite a degree of animosity shown for posters who post "what they hear". It has definitely trimmed down the genuine insider information whereas trolls seem to be increasing. They know they can spend a couple of weeks winding people up, who can't help but respond to "ITK bullshitters". They take the bait! That level of posting then stops people who actually may know something because they cba to get the responses back I don't know what the mods can do. Banning it is useless. If you believe it, good for you, if you don't, who cares. It really shouldn't be a big deal. Usually I believe it when it is announced...especially these days!

No "people" have said this The point being made was that international football is different. For every manager who has had international success only, there will also be a manager that has had success at club and international level. Some had success at club level before international level, some didn't, some had their breakthrough at international level You are creating an argument in order to argue against it Whereas your posts have been quite clear. You think that success at club level is precedent to a good appointment. Otherwise, they are "unproven or proven failures". But history in football tells you that this isn't entirely true. I won't be calling an appointment of Lee Carsley a disaster appointment because throughout the history of football managers have had great success in international football without ever really bothering with club football So the examples are important in this discussion. Not a "backwards argument" and certainly does not mean we should "look for failures" And for your last point, it is not like saying that. It is like saying that you should not start writing people off before they arrive. When people say they won't judge or that others shouldn't, it doesn't mean you can't have your moan about it. Feel free to. But there's a few posters here who clearly don't think success at club level is precedent to being a success as England manager. And I agree.

I’d like the idea of Ange tbf Jose Mourinho has a lot of friends in England but has unfortunately just taken the Fenerbache role To be honest, I’ll support whoever the FA puts in. Be it English or not. If it’s Lee Carsley I won’t bitch or moan about his lack of good club experience because it doesn’t matter. Southgate had next to none, de la Fuente had none. Go back years and Beckenbauer had none. Literally that blokes first job! Look up Alberto Parreira. Was an expert at international football. Had 0 club success. Joachim Low was managing at some terrible levels before joining the German national set up. Before him, Germany appointed Klinsmann who had a good World Cup, against all expectations Our very own Mark Hughes went to Wales first Point being, if the coach is good enough he will be a success. People seem to rubbish Lee Carsley. The man won the U21 European Championship. Maybe he was lucky too

Lee Carsley has been a successful youth coach and won the U21 Euros He has had a similar trajectory to de la Fuente For me, he needs longer in the U21s but he’s a potential future England manager for sure

It’s been reported today that the FA want Pep and are happy to wait a year. If Southgate didn’t get the level of vitriol he would be the perfect man to stay for 12 months to sort the transition. Such a shame it had to come to this English fans are some of the worst in Europe

Precisely. The measly fan nitpicking of who those knock out games included counts for nothing. The fact is, as manager he won them. We have only been knocked out / beaten by either finalists or winners of the tournaments he has been in charge in. That's impressive People slam him for losing to Croatia, as an example. They were bloody good in that tournament. They may not be football giants in the ilk of Brazil or Argentina, but relative to that specific tournament they were. They got to the final after all It's been the best time following England and unfortunately the highs have come with the lows. Really, we were beaten by better sides and in knock out football that's just the way it goes. I think this England side will win something soon and a lot of that groundwork has come from Southgate's work at St George's park. It's quite well known in the football world just how much of his brain power has gone into St George's and that legacy will not be forgotten. Amongst those in the game anyway Fans are fickle. Always will be. The same blokes screaming for Klopp now will be slamming him and calling him a failure if he didn't make it past his first quarter final. Such is life

Comes to something that when I saw Jack Barrett’s name, I instantly thought they misspelt Jake Garrett It just has such an amateur feel to the club at the moment

Rovers haven’t made back to back tournament finals….

I get that football is a game of opinions but this is a bad one There is zero argument for it being a foul by Kane. He was first to the ball and got 100% of it. His studs weren’t up. He used his laces Dumfries went studs up and was second to the ball. There’s no way what Kane did was worse or has more of an argument We can argue to the cows come home over whether Dumfries’ late challenge should have been given as a penalty. But that’s where it should end

Are you being serious about it being a foul on the defender lol? Kane got 100% of the ball…………………………