islander200

Why is he head coach and not manager if he is running recruitment too?

2? Dembele, Ruddy, Stansfield,Pak, the young midfielder from Birmingham this morning...that's 5 The media haven't mentioned a player he wants that hasn't played for him yet Sourness hadn't worked with Neill before...Tugay and Friedal where internationals who came here after only plating top flight football...a bit different than raiding league one Birmingham

Yeah that's why I think they should be leading the recruitment, not Eustace and his ex player brigade

Am I professing I know more than Eustace?By the way he is head coach...not the manager?. There is a difference most head coaches don't have much of a say in recruitment Dembele spells on the bench at every club he has been at.Woeful goals and assist record. I think it would be a poor signing and I think better can be found for the same money both fee and wages he is likely to cost .Be a lazy signing too plumping for someone the head coach knows

The clue should be the fact Eustace was appointed Head coach not manager. You are 100% correct in what you said about Brentford and Brighton, both head coaches trusting in the recruitment and not giving lists of ex players to sign It's a different story if Eustace was promised he could sign who he wants if it came within budget , but you would expect his title to be manager if that was the case

But eustace admitted he had little to do with Ohashi and Gueye?Would you not say they have been good signings so far? Imo recruitment should be presenting a list of players for the head coach to look at and then he makes a decision The thing that is making me most uncomfortable is that every target that has been mentioned as a player Eustace is keen on are all ex players of his Ruddy and Dembele wouldn't be good signings imo

I am going off what unleaded said...he was over ruled on Gueye and Ohashi...Eustace admitted he had little to do with those signings. I never said Eustace wanted Hogan as you well know I said hypothetically if he had the choice of Hogan or Ohashi I'd expect him to pick the player he knows If this Yeboah is a genuine target by recruitment and Eustace had a choice between him and Dembele again I'd expect Eustace to plump for Dembele due to working with him before.That does not mean Dembele would be the better signing

Where any of JDTs signings picked out by him/ex players? Recruitment found players available for the positions wanted and then JDT had the final say on who to pursue, that I can agree with What I don't agree with us us seemingly restricting ourselves to signing the head coaches ex players John eustace will have no idea if their is a better player than Dembele in Japan, China or timbuktu, but the recruitment side might

Because he wasn't offered the opportunity to sign Hogan instead? Eustace said himself he had little to do with the signings of ohashi and gueye

It's my opinion that Ruddy and Dembele ain't good options. Your argument seems to be that Eustace wants them so that is all that matters. Being presented a group of players by recruitment and the head coach choosing the best option fair enough, but the head coach insisting on ex players I'm not keen on especially when in my opinion the players are either past it or inconsistent with no end product

How?he said himself Ohashi and Gueye where the work of tye recruitment side. I said "I'd expect" Eustace to go for Hogan .Wouldn't you? He knows Hogan he didn't know ohashi

Well his title is head coach?Why not manager Why bring in Gestede, Owen and Park?

I said previously I think he is doing a good job of coaching and setting up the team it has nothing to do with JDT.The players Eustace supposedly wants are leaving me underwhelmed,recruitment did a good job with Gueye and Ohashi and I'd like to see what else they can bring in instead of the likes of Ruddy or Dembele

No but park ,gestede and Owen are looking at players from a larger pool than Eustace is again he had nothing to do with Gueye or Ohashi At most clubs now the manager/head coach has little to do with the signing of players

Recruitment are looking at players all over the world, the manager seemingly wants players he has worked with before. He has admitted he knew little of Ohashi and Gueye If he was presented with Ohashi or Scott Hogan as a signing then I'd expect Eustace to plump for Hogan due to familiarity and league experience, that doesn't mean Hogan would be the right signing. Eustace is head coach not the manager, said it himself his job is to coach the squad

No but dembele spent time out of the side due to poor performances and because of a lack of effort in training etc So yeah I think I can say that on him

My point is I think recruitment should be leading our signings not Eustace like it is at most clubs now and I don't rate the players that the head coach supposedly wants Mowbray signed ex players and players from his ex clubs none where a great success You sign Eustace ex players then he finds himself sacked or quits then we are left with those players No point bringing in Park, Gestede and Owen just to sign players from the managers phone book

Yeah but you can hardly say they will have a winning mentality. Dembele for example is a bit of a journey man now who has spent spells on the bench at every club he has been at including Pboro

If he wants the recruitment team to find someone different fair enough, but if he is insisting on Dembele and blocking other signings then I don't agree with that I don't want Ruddy here and I'm not that keen on Dembele either, I'm not really arsed if Eustace rates them or not ,like someone else said Mowbray had a fascination with it or signing from ex clubs I do think Eustace is doing a good job of coaching and setting up the team but the game has moved on from when managers had all the say with recruitment

Most of the players on his list got relegated last season

He knew little of ohashi and Gueye.We have brought in a new recruitment team...Eustace title Is head coach here I wouldn't expect Eustace to have the knowledge of the other leagues rhat recruitment will have.

The 2 signings that have had the biggest impact are Ohashi and Gueye, signings Eustace had little to do with. I agree ,we have brought people in to lead recruitment and although I think Eustace should have a say I do find it concerning his list consists of Birmingham City players a club that got relegated last season.

They didn't sell Hughes until their valuation was met. He would be a better option than Dolan as a 10 imo,but I'd rather if a fee like that was spent to go on the best winger we can get

Probably is a release clause if he was willing to commit to a 5 year deal with a league one club

Was that not prior to signing Mcfadz and Batth? I've seen reports Cooper is close to a deal with Hull