It wasn't an opinion, it was one of numerous examples of things that affect the matchday experience that by your logic shouldn't be discussed because we only go to watch a football match. Dismissing people because you consider their opinion to be negative or critical is IMO not conducive to allowing debate to flow on a messageboard. My personal preference would be to remove Sweet Caroline, ideally with no music to be played at full time, allowing a more natural crowd driven noise if we win.

I go to watch the team, but if you are totally disinterested in the topic, why have you contributed with an opinion so heavily? We go to watch the team, why does it matter if the food is crap/overpriced/brilliant, the programmes are or aren't sold, they play music too loud, the bogs are a mess or pristinely maintained, the stewards are fair/inadequate, whether we install a standing section, whether the ground is more than half empty/totally full? Lets not discuss anything but the game?

Lucky to not have many injuries up until now, yes. Had we had more injuries, it may have been a different situation with such a thin squad. We have a core group of 13-15 players that I have confidence in to give anyone a game at this level. Beyond that, there isn't much. Tomasson has started perfectly, but ultimately I am not interested in platitudes about how "hard" the club are working, I judge on who has signed. If we drop any points due to being particularly weak in a specific area, then Tomasson will have the right to say, I am doing what I can but I need more help here and I feel let down. I would welcome Styles but I don't think there has ever been strong interest this summer and judging by the quotes following the Morton deal, I fear that we won't sign another midfielder in general which would leave us very, very short in there.

Yep, definitely not Black Eyed Peas, agreed there! Im not sure there even needs to be music at all personally. Totally against goal music, at the end is not as bad but still I think there is perhaps no need to blast music over the crowd.

I started quite a lot of debate about peoples views on part of the matchday experience. As per usual, your response is along the lines of stop being negative/stop complaining.

A long, long way to go before he needs to worry about what national team to play for!

I suppose the problem with direct comparisons is that we are not playing the same formation. The key with Brereton is making sure that we have targets very much lined up, hopefully of a decent fee and good calibre to instantly be signed. I am not convinced that will happen though.

They have signed Freuler from Atalanta and Mangala who they had only just signed prior to that game and Yates who is carrying an injury also missed that game, plus they are rumoured to want another midfielder. Add in Lewis O'Brien who they have signed and he might struggle (same with Cafu) to even get a place in the 25 man squad.

I wouldn't even say it would be a luxury, could be a potential way of adding a number of goals.

He reads the game quite well anyway but as soon as he plays someone with an aeriel threat, he would likely struggle. Moving him from left back also creates a weakness there. 3 changes? I definitely would not take Pickering out, Edun was horrendous yesterday whereas Pickering was one of our best players. Dack is the one potential change that I would perhaps go with out of that.

I wonder if it is worth looking at Nottingham Forest's squad with them signing so many players, perhaps a few Championship ready players will become surplus to requirements. We need experience and we need a midfielder, he is not a world beater but how about someone like Jack Colback who can also cover left back as a much more steady option than Edun if Pickering gets injured? Or even Ryan Yates.

Tomasson has started the season as well as mathematically possible, winning every game. We have been lucky that our threadbare squad going into the season had only really Carter missing but now even a slight hint of a few injuries and we are looking short, we need players in ASAP and if we drop any points with a small squad in the meantime, then Tomasson can look to Broughton and indeed Venkys and feel let down. And no, I am not asking for rubbish players to be signed to make up the numbers.

And the team is much stronger with a regular goalscorer in it, I think was the point being made. You speak as if the choice of music impacts upon whether we win or not.

New foreign coaches with exciting new and groundbreaking ideas, or so I have heard.

Expected goals. In all 3 games we have protected leads so meaningless twaddle.

He should not be on par with our highest earner.

Liverpool keen to hang on to defender Sepp van der Berg https://mol.im/a/11109607 via http://dailym.ai/android

Theyd be stupid to not accept such a sum for a player who hasnt come close to meriting such a big fee.

40m for Gordon who tries but is nothing special would be a great deal for Everton.

Markanday and Rankin Costello both picked up injuries for the under 21s, leaving us potentially even shorter.

Sweet Caroline was a consequence of England at the Euros but is a little cheesy and irritating in general. Obviously if it stays though id like to hear it 21 more times this season. No idea what to change it to.

You cant possibly know if Tomasson would or wouldnt consider or be asked and pressured into considering financial consequences of his team selections. No one can ever dismiss that point out of hand. And even if he did consider it, he wouldnt say as such publically.

Cant help but think that the music upon victory needs changing.

I don't think that I have seen the total revolution in style under JDT that many imply. It is much more subtle IMO. A lot of talk about how we wouldn't have won that last season, I don't necessarily agree, we won lots of gritty, hard fought games last season and battered a few teams too. There is talk about the fluid front 4, in the main they have fixed positions including ones that have historically created criticism, Gallagher wide the obvious example. None of this is critical in any way, football is about results and it's 100% successful at the moment, plus I do think that at times the managers tactical prowess has shone through already. So far, so good.

The key should be to put out the best team though, and get results. If that includes loan players, so be it. Maybe even we can loan out Carter once more if we end up signing 2.