[Archived] The +/- Game 09/10

[RoverJoexx]

After a non-event deadline day yest and a week break of non-action premier football. Like to start this again to spice up some interest on the board.

See who comes up on top as the players majority of us would love to see them succeed at that position at the end of season. Hope I'm able to manage my time well to mend it daily.

Let's lay out the rules now;

1) Everyone only able to vote once daily( not going to keep track so I hope you guys be discipline enough )

2) There will be 4 departments to vote. They are Keeper, Defence, Midfield and Forward. Defence/Midfield will further breakdown to varies position.

3) Each time you make 2 '+' votes and 2 '-' votes but not all on the same player and votes make must be from different department.

Eg : You can't make 2 votes on Samba, and if you make a + vote on Samba you can't make your another + vote on defence department.

4) Each player will have 10 life. Any player that reaches 20 life will win in his position likewise those reaches 0 life will be oust.

5) Some players will have more than one position base on where Big Sam had try to played them last season/preseason, please state their POSITION when making the votes thanks.

*Players base on our official website 1st team profiles 442 formation;

Keeper Dept:

Robinson- 10

Brown---- 10

Defence Dept:

Rightback :

Jacobsen---- 10

Salgado----- 10

Chimbonda- 10

Leftback :

Givet-------- 10

Chimbonda- 10

Salgado----- 10

Olsson------- 9

Centerback :

Nelsen------- 10

Samba------- 10

Givet--------- 11

Khizanishvili- 10

Chimbonda-- 10

Midfield Dept:

Right Midfield :

Diouf----- 10

Emerton- 10

Dunn------ 9

Hoilett--- 10

Reid------ 10

Left Midfield :

Pedersen- 10

Diouf------ 10

Dunn------ 10

Center Midfield :

Dunn----- 11

Grella---- 10

Emerton- 10

Andrews- 10

Reid------ 10

Nzonzi---- 10

Salgado-- 10

Forward Dept:

McCarthy- 10

Roberts--- 10

Kalinic---- 10

Di Santo-- 10

Hoilett----- 10

*Note - I have not include E.V Heerden due to not seen enough of him yet and Doran/Fielding since they're backups for now. Intend to put our super human Salgado in all positions but i'll leave with RB, LB and CM for now.

Pick your fav player and get your votes in now.

Votes updated as in post # 1

Will get the ball rolling first

+Givet(CB)

+Dunn(CM)

-Olsson

-Dunn(RM)

[CAPT KAYOS]

May be too early yet but...

+ JACOBSEN (RB) - at last a proper right back

+ DUNN (CM)- given our resources we need him desperately (fit)

- ANDREWS (CM) - don't mind him being here but has been poor in the games so far

- SAM (MGR) - unambitious & unconfident tactics for the Wet spam game.

[riverside returns]

+ Givet (CB) outstanding start.

+ Robinson (GK) Looks fit and started well

- Andrews (CM) not good enough but tries hard

- Reid (CM) cant stay fit

[RoverJoexx]

Keeper Dept:

Robinson- 11

Brown---- 10

Defence Dept:

Rightback :

Jacobsen---- 11

Salgado----- 10

Chimbonda- 10

Leftback :

Givet-------- 10

Chimbonda- 10

Salgado----- 10

Olsson------- 9

Centerback :

Nelsen------- 10

Samba------- 10

Givet--------- 12

Khizanishvili- 10

Chimbonda-- 10

Midfield Dept:

Right Midfield :

Diouf----- 10

Emerton- 10

Dunn------ 9

Hoilett--- 10

Reid------ 10

Left Midfield :

Pedersen- 10

Diouf------ 10

Dunn------ 10

Center Midfield :

Dunn----- 12

Grella---- 10

Emerton- 10

Andrews- 8

Reid------ 9

Nzonzi---- 10

Salgado-- 10

Forward Dept:

McCarthy- 10

Roberts--- 10

Kalinic---- 10

Di Santo-- 10

Hoilett----- 10

In :

Out :

[LeChuck]

+ Emerton (CM)

+ Robinson (GK)

- Andrews (CM)

- Roberts

[braddock]

+ kalinic (the new jansen)

+ chimbonda (promising debut)

- dunn (wasteful)

- samba (bad start with missed interceptions, but i'm sure he'll get plenty of +'s from me in the future)

[Al]

+ Givet - Superb Defender.

+ Dunn - Only flair player in team.

- Andrews - Never going to be good enough.

- Reid - Will take up a place in the team for a few weeks before Sam realises he is never going to get back to his best.

[joey_big_nose]

I think you have to quote the relevent positions

+ Givet (CB)

+ Dunn (CM)

- Pedersen (LM)

- Andrews (RM)

Just basing this on West Ham. To be honest Grella, Hoilett and Chimbonda deserve a 'plus' too. But rules are rules

[rebelmswar]

Givet (DL) +1 The man has single handedly brought up my opinion of the French.

Hoilett(RM) +1 First hope of a GREAT player that we have developed for some time.

Reid(CM) -1 I can not see him coming back from what has happened.

Diouf(LM) -1 Disappointed with his winding up ability this season so far. (Lack of spittle is a plus though)

[rovers1993]

Dunn (CM) +1

Givet (CB) +1

Andrews (CM) -1

Emerton (RM) -1

[rovers_rob]

+ Grella (CM)

+ Samba(CB)

- Andrews (CM)

- Olsson (LB)

[Florida Rover]

Dunn (CM) +

Givet(CB) +

Andrews (CM)-

Olsson(LB) -

[RoverJoexx]

Keeper Dept:

Robinson- 12

Brown---- 10

Defence Dept:

Rightback :

Jacobsen---- 11

Salgado----- 10

Chimbonda- 10

Leftback :

Givet-------- 11

Chimbonda- 11

Salgado----- 10

Olsson------- 7

Centerback :

Nelsen------- 10

Samba------- 10

Givet--------- 16

Khizanishvili- 10

Chimbonda-- 10

Midfield Dept:

Right Midfield :

Diouf----- 10

Emerton-- 9

Dunn------ 9

Hoilett--- 11

Reid------ 10

Left Midfield :

Pedersen- 9

Diouf------ 9

Dunn------ 10

Center Midfield :

Dunn----- 15

Grella---- 11

Emerton- 11

Andrews- 2

Reid------ 7

Nzonzi---- 10

Salgado-- 10

Forward Dept:

McCarthy- 10

Roberts--- 9

Kalinic---- 11

Di Santo-- 10

Hoilett----- 10

In :

Out :

Note : Guys we have quite afew versatile players in our club, make it easy for me please state their position thanks.

Those votes with no position ill take it as the position they last played for us.

[The1mattjansen]

+ Dunn - Great ability, we really need him playing

+ Salgado - Because i'm affraid of the repercussions of leaving him out

- Andrews - Horrible

- Diouf - Not what i'd expected. Slow, limited, but clearly very suited to Sam's style.

[rog of the rovers]

Isnt this just another pop at Andrews?

Honestly so far

+ MGP (LM)

+ Chimbonda (LB)

- Zurab (CB)

- Brown (GK)

[Miker]

+ Grella (CM)

+ Dunn (CM)

- Olsson (LB)

- Zurab (CB)

Seriously? So many votes for Andrews? He's not our worst player by far...

[67splitscreen]

+ Givet CD

+ Dunne CM

- Olsoon LB

- Diouf RM

[RoverJoexx]

Andrews - You can choose to support by giving him a + vote but honest speak in this game someone has to go first.. 1 life left and think ill give him the final nail.

The1mattjansen - Please state the position for Salgado thanks

Note : After some thoughts, i'm taking out Reid RM position and Salgado CM position due to irrelevent contest.

+ Emerton(CM)

+ Kalinic

- Andrews (Out)

- Roberts

[RoverJoexx]

Keeper Dept:

Robinson- 12

Brown---- 9

Defence Dept:

Rightback :

Jacobsen---- 11

Salgado----- 10

Chimbonda- 10

Leftback :

Givet-------- 11

Chimbonda- 12

Salgado----- 10

Olsson------- 5

Centerback :

Nelsen------- 10

Samba------- 10

Givet--------- 17

Khizanishvili- 8

Chimbonda-- 10

Midfield Dept:

Right Midfield :

Diouf----- 8

Emerton-- 9

Dunn------ 9

Hoilett--- 11

Left Midfield :

Pedersen- 10

Diouf------ 9

Dunn------ 10

Center Midfield :

Dunn----- 18

Grella---- 12

Emerton- 12

Reid------ 7

Nzonzi---- 10

Forward Dept:

McCarthy- 10

Roberts--- 8

Kalinic---- 12

Di Santo-- 10

Hoilett----- 10

In :

Out : Andrews(CM)

[RoverRich]

+ Hoilett (RM)

+ Chimbonda (LB)

- Reid (CM)

- Roberts (FW)

[Al]

+ Hoilett (RM)

+ Dunn (CM)

- Reid (CM)

- McCarthy (F)

[alexanders]

+ Dunn (CM)

+ Kalinic (ST)

- Andrews (CM)

- Olsson (LB)

[Balwer]

+ Dunn (CM)

+ Givet (CB)

- Brown (GK)

- Dunn (RM)

[CAPT KAYOS]

how can people pick players when they have not even played yet?

[Lurid Coat]

+Hoilett (RM)

+Givet (CB)

-Andrews (CM)

-Reid (CM)