blue phil Posted May 28, 2009 Share Posted May 28, 2009 Shearer is no Dalglish intellectually and would have been an unmitigated disaster imo, I said as much at the time. BUT he does have one thing in common with Kenny....neither would come anywhere near us without JW type wealth to hand. If Shearer is no Dalglish intellectually (which is very questionable) then both are way above Ince in that department . It's the individual that counts not some beliefs about age and experience nor some silly rules put forward by the Prem league . There's very little evidence at this moment in time to suggest that Shearer will be a bad manager in the long run . Great players can make great managers . Inexperienced managers can prove effective - as Barcelona showed this season . We should remember that Shearer was first offered the job years ago when still a player . We ended up with someone whose credentials were far superior ...........Ray Harford ! Whether Shearer could have done better with the players at Ewood than the dross at Newcastle we'll never know ...not even you Gordon Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.