2025 Summer Transfer Thread. 😂

[RevidgeBlue]

22 minutes ago, islander200 said:

I'm sure Gestede said the same thing in the Allardyce podcast.

Eddie put him under a bit more pressure with his questioning and he blurted out "My job is to make sure academy players develop so we can sell them" 

Going off both those podcasts he is an absolute clown." The fans should be happy we have a team to play on a Saturday and Tuesday night"

Yes and since then of course Suhail let his views slip in the FF by saying spending doesn't necessarily guarantee success. **

So what Gestede said is probably basically correct.

**Maybe it doesn't but not spending over an extended period of time is an absolutely 100% guaranteed way to fail.

[CambridgeRover]

16 minutes ago, RevidgeBlue said:

Spending doesn't necessarily guarantee success. **

Nothing in football guarantees success but as you say a lot guarantees failures

Edited 2 hours ago by CambridgeRover

[simongarnerisgod]

26 minutes ago, RevidgeBlue said:

Yes and since then of course Suhail let his views slip in the FF by saying spending doesn't necessarily guarantee success. **

no it`s does`nt, but not spending also puts you at risk of relegation,especially when other clubs in the division are indeed spending,this clown is supposed to be a "business man " is`nt he

[M_B]

1 hour ago, aletheia said:

Your sophistry is tiresome.

It really isn't a difficult question to answer. 

[M_B]

1 hour ago, islander200 said:

What Is Gestedes idea of success here tho?

Staying in the division?

Hoping to hit the jackpot with a few bargain basement signings to make a few million profit to lessen the money required from the owners to keep the club running?

To develop some players from the academy to sell at the earliest opportunity?

Imo he isn't here to try help build a team that can get us promoted. Promotion is not on the agenda here.

Broughton might not have been very good at his job but imo  he wanted the club to progress and wasn't just looking at saving the owners a few quid 

It does depend on what your idea of success is, I'd say play offs, the question is how long they get. 

[M_B]

7 hours ago, bluebruce said:

No. Are you a windup?

Not at all, all I asked was would you like to see Gestede succeed ?

I wasn't being smart, it's just that some never even gave him a chance right from the off, in fact he was getting grief before he'd even started.

I'm certainly hoping he knows what he's doing football wise. 

[chaddyrovers]

9 hours ago, roversfan99 said:

Still not entirely sure what Ismael is trying to do.

did you understand how the tactical plan on Saturday from Ismael? 

[Leonard Venkhater]

33 minutes ago, M_B said:

Not at all, all I asked was would you like to see Gestede succeed ?

I wasn't being smart, it's just that some never even gave him a chance right from the off, in fact he was getting grief before he'd even started.

I'm certainly hoping he knows what he's doing football wise. 

He doesn't...

[chaddyrovers]

7 hours ago, lraC said:

I don’t know of any other club doing that once, let alone twice, although to be honest, I maintain it was a smokescreen really. 

didn't we do it when Appleton was here and he wanted to sign DJ Campbell and Jerome Thomas? 

2 hours ago, islander200 said:

What Is Gestedes idea of success here tho?

Staying in the division?

Hoping to hit the jackpot with a few bargain basement signings to make a few million profit to lessen the money required from the owners to keep the club running?

To develop some players from the academy to sell at the earliest opportunity?

Imo he isn't here to try help build a team that can get us promoted. Promotion is not on the agenda here.

Broughton might not have been very good at his job but imo  he wanted the club to progress and wasn't just looking at saving the owners a few quid 

Miller mentioned getting to the PL during his interview and that the plan under Gestede and Ismael. 

I think Ismael is Gestede's choice for the head coach job and they are aligned along with Adam Owen. People forget about Adam Owen and his range of contacts he has 

I also think Ismael wanted to push on this season and I don't think he expect Brittain and Travis to move on and I think he expect them to re-sign here long term. This hasn't happened for him but he isn't to blame and he has dealt with the situation with understand but telling the supporters what has gone on. hence why we seen his mention this season has a transition season 

Edited 42 minutes ago by chaddyrovers

[bluebruce]

1 hour ago, M_B said:

Not at all, all I asked was would you like to see Gestede succeed ?

I wasn't being smart, it's just that some never even gave him a chance right from the off, in fact he was getting grief before he'd even started.

I'm certainly hoping he knows what he's doing football wise. 

I told you I always want the best for the club. I answered you. It shouldn't need outwardly stating but if that means Gestede doing a good job with recruitment then hopefully he does a good job. If he does, he'll get no criticism from me for it. Theoretically I'd like every employee of the club to succeed. My only caveat would be sometimes it can be papering over the cracks and dragging out our purgatory with Venkys, but it's hard to know what if anything could get rid of them anyway.

Gestede's appointment gained rightful criticism because he was completely unqualified for the job, especially at a club of this calibre. He also dropped us like a bad habit when he was a player, so that won't have helped, despite the club's bizarre attempts to paint him as some club legend.

It's up to him to make all of that irrelevant by doing great work. The jury is still very much out on that for now, especially since the contract situation has deteriorated again since the Broughton days were swapped for the Gestede era.